I’m not dissing on this, but why is Tomlinson NOT doing a talk show? She’s got so much more to offer than a game show like format. I hope this show can progress into something more.

I'm here to support Tomlinson, who is geninely one of the funniest stand-up comedians I've ever seen. If we can't get Tomlinson her own talk show (which she is 100% worthy of rocking), is there a chance we could compromise and let her have an opening monologue before the games start so that she can show off her comedic chops?

"YOU KNOW WHAT THAT MEANS!"..."You don't, it's our first show." lol

The answer "Friend" to lesser known tv shows was absolutely lethal. Knocked me out my seat.

Please let Taylor have a talk show with this game apart of it. She deserves more space to be naturally funny!

5:08 She gets it. CBS needs to let Taylor sit in a room with whoever she wants and plan the show she wants.

I went into this expecting a talk show. While I’m still severely disappointed it’s not (because Taylor absolutely deserves one), she did a wonderful job and it was fun to watch!

My wish for Taylor is that this is enough to propel her to better things. I think she would rock a Graham Norton type of show!

I personally didn't love the format but I came here for Tomlinson and she didn't disappoint. Whitney was a pleasant surprise, but I didn't know the other guests. Looking forward to more Taylor Tomlinson in the future.

The grand prize of “Taylor Tomlinson’s Father’s approval” needs to be presented in person by Taylor Tomlinson’s actual father.

Taylor needs a talk show, PLEASE!!!! She is one of my favorite modern comedians. So naturally funny and charismatic Her energy and humor is captivating and makes you want to keep watching!

I love her stand-up so much.

This show needs to start with Taylor getting to do a monologue! She's a great comedian and needs to get more spotlight! That said I actually like this game concept. Reminds me of NPR's Wait Wait Don't Tell Me turning its attention to TikTok. I'm enjoying it!

This game would be great as a segment ON TAYLOR'S OWN TALK SHOW!

Taylor is FAB, as per usual, but it's very telling that the best moments of this whole episode were the unscripted/off-hand comments by Taylor and the guests. They are all SO talented and thrive in those little moments that give the show momentum again. There is so much gimmicky structure; the comics need space to FLORISH! I hope Taylor gets a real talk show one day!!!

never has a game show been so in danger of bombing every second.

You can feel CBS being terrified of the truly improvised moments that make these formats shine. Also, the studio lighting does not help the vibe at alllll. But I loved everybody on screen.