Nightmare Shining Armor to round out the family. EDIT: Thought of a name - Shattered Shield

Twilight Sparkle is suffering everyone's worst nightmare: being a college student

Ooh I'm imagining that after Luna becomes de-nightmarififed she's look horrified as to what happened and she decides that she needs to take down Twilight with the rest of the main six!

Please give us a good evil Fluttershy! I can’t even imagine what would cause her, maybe the land becoming barren due to the Eternal Night (tying into this AU? Oh how cool if there was a way to make a full evil Mane 6!)

So if SHE is a friendless nerd she gets to have a cool shadow form but ME? NOTHING!

Divorce horse is just funny. Cadence as the pony of distaste is just funny and great

I always imagined her nightmare being more like a version of cozy glow, seeing friendship as a way to control and be an empress.

Honestly there are not enough 'evil Twilight' concepts out there that aren't Midnight.

Valley girl Twilight Sparkle isn't real she can't hurt you

I have seen many people asking for a Nightmare Shining Armor…

super cool design! i love the idea of her hair losing any pink hue due to stress lol. honestly would love to see a midnight sunset. might be interesting with the fact that she's already associated with sun imagery

She's Moondancer now! (Maybe she could team up with her, actually.)

i always feel that twilight was meant to be a villain, but only because she met her friends in season 1, was she able to actually grow out of her own vision of the world and move on to become a princess. otherwise, she could easily have been a crazed scientist

For story I think a sort of evil/misguided clown nightmare Pinkie would be amazing - like she wants everyone to smile so bad that she ends up hurting them

Nightmare Big Mac!

I would really love to see your vision for an evil Moon Dancer. I love all the evil twilight theories and considering Moon Dancer is supposed to represent who Twilight used to be and where she could have ended up had she not made friends, I think she's a valid character to consider for a downfall.

Love the backstory makes the name and this "evilfied" twilight really work! i wonder if through destiny the other main five eventually become twilight's friends and accidentally bring Celestia and the day back?

I want to see Fluttershy or pinkie. I think they would look cool