The fact that he found pizza in SH and is just casually eating is the most horrifying thing. Could you imagine? I would be like, yep, hes a psychopath.

It just occurred to me Eddie had to have looked in the fridge to find the body. The pizza scene isn't weird, he's been looking for food all along.

Walking around Silent Hill with no shoes? I don't know man... that is very scary to me.

James: This town is full of monsters! How can you just sit there and eat pizza?

To be honest, I always saw as a long-time victim of bullying who would've turned to food for comfort and likely developed a severe binge eating disorder/food addiction, and the best way to perceive them in my opinion, are on the same way as drug addicts/alcoholics. So the bowling alley scene could have been him resorting to things such as him picking through the trash in order to "get his fix," of his "drug." So to me, I feel the scenes with him eating moreso just show how far gone he is into his disordered eating habits. Because of the excessive eating, he obviously would have gained a lot of weight, which would have made him a victim of bullying from his peers.

Imagine going in to audition for a psychological horror game, getting the role, and then learning you've been cast as 'guy eating bowling alley pizza'.

Another thing about Eddie sitting down is that it hides that he's tall and threatening until he shows his true colors.

12:41 the town isn't actually abandoned. For it's residents, it's a normal town. For the people it draws in, it's whatever the town wants them to see. Kind of like some alternate reality or something, in the same way the town turns into its rusty bloody dimension. We are playing the game as James, we don't know what Eddie is seeing, he could be seeing the town's real residents. The whole abandoned mining town thing is from the movie, its not canon in the games

To me the most damning piece of foreshadowing that Eddie was lying about his guilt wasn't his body language or the circumstances you find him in, but the strong implication that the monsters look like cops to him.

Eddie: “You see Pizza too? For me, it’s always like this.”

Silent Hill scores are among the best horror, if not the best horror scores I've ever heard. Dreamlike, hellish, a soft torture while others are blunt stabs to the bones. The music hits a nerve in me.